Response from the publisher, Zuhair Bilal:

It is enough for me that you have acknowledged the reality of reincarnation (Taqammus). Every science revolving around reincarnation has not been the sole axis of my research; my focus is more specific.

We do not agree with your dismissal of Ibn Shu’bah’s book. I referred you to a book containing the words of an Infallible (Ma'sum) to verify the transition of a woman into a man, yet you cast doubt upon the text and the author. Then, you jumped forward to demand a dedicated chapter on the subject. I will not be led by your "leaps" again. Go to the book to verify it for yourself. If you are not convinced by the Hadith, then produce a work that aligns with your convictions—refute the Hadith and the author, and provide arguments that convince the reader of its falsehood.

Nevertheless, in the Nineteenth Chapter, I will prove that a man becomes a woman. Peace be the conclusion.

The protester’s rebuttal: "I do not acknowledge reincarnation because you wrote about it, but rather because Imam Ali—Sublime is His Praise—mentioned it in one of his sermons. This is something that neither you nor anyone else researching reincarnation and transmigration has mentioned, despite the fact that his words are clear."

Response from the publisher, Zuhair Bilal: "The spread of the idea of Divine Justice among people removes envy from souls and